A Viral Syrian Moment: Will It Be Different This Time?
A single photo of a drowned Syrian child shocked the world's conscience this week and focused international attention on a conflict that has left a quarter million dead and sent 4 million fleeing in the past four years.
But beyond the powerful emotional impact and a surge in aid donations, will it change the way the international community responds to Syria's war or to the surge of migrants descending on Europe?
Syria has had similar, shocking moments in the spotlight over the past few years:
But little, if anything, changed after these episodes. In fact, suffering increased, fighting intensified and more and more people fled Syria or were killed.
This week, the picture of the child, 3-year-old Aylan Kurdi, appeared on front pages and social media, where it elicited anguish and outrage, and was held up as a symbol of the world's failure to deal both the Syrian war and the migrant crisis.
"I hope the world will learn something from it," Aylan's father, Abdullah Kurdi, told reporters on Friday.
"I hope this people will be helped, that these massacres are stopped. We are human beings, just like Westerners," said Kurdi, who also lost his 5-year-old son and his wife when their dinghy capsized as they attempted to reach Europe. The lone survivor in his family, Kurdi buried his wife and two boys Friday in Kobani, the northern Syrian town they had fled.
The photo has added to the pressure European leaders were already feeling when it comes to their policies on accepting Syrian refugees.
Britain's prime minister, David Cameron, said Thursday that the photo of Aylan Kurdi "deeply moved" him. He said Britain would take in thousands of Syrians directly from refugee camps and announced an extra $100 million in aid.
"Europe is facing a moment of truth," Antonio Guterres, the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees, said Friday. "This is the time to reaffirm the values upon which it was built."
However, there's been no sign that any Western or Middle Eastern government is preparing to alter its policy toward the war in Syria, the root cause of the refugee crisis. The largest number of those heading to Europe are from Syria, though many are also coming from other Middle Eastern and African states.
Other long-running conflicts have also had moments where a single event prompted outpourings of sympathy, outrage and support. But in most cases, the moment passed and the conflicts continued to grind on.
A 2012 video and aggressive social media campaign put the spotlight on the abuses of Joseph Kony, the Ugandan-born leader of the Lord's Resistance Army responsible for abducting tens of thousands of children and forcing them to become child soldiers. The goal: to capture him and bring him to justice.
That did lead to stepped-up action: The U.S. military sent in a significantly larger team to track him down. Four senior members of Kony's faction, wanted by the International Criminal Court, have since been arrested or surrendered. But Kony himself has once again disappeared into the shadows.
Last year, the world was outraged after Boko Haram militants kidnapped 276 schoolgirls in Nigeria. A global "Bring Back Our Girls" movement was launched and continues to agitate for the girls' safe return. But last week, the girls' families marked 500 days since their disappearance.
So what might this all suggest for Syria's refugees?
The photo of Aylan Kurdi "broke our heart and shattered our soul," said Italy's prime minister, Matteo Renzi. But, he conceded, "We have seen too many European leaders who have been moved, but very few have taken action."
Perhaps that will change with the European Union meets on Sept. 14. In the meantime, everything has changed for Aylan Kurdi's father, Abdullah, who is back in Kobani. He said he no longer wants to live anywhere else.
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.